Susan Tice Niethammer - Reinhart Realtors

Susan Tice Niethammer


About Me

"Susan N. has enjoyed tremendous success in her real estate practice for many reasons, starting with hard work and persistence. She is high energy, a relentless negotiator, and a creative problem solver for her clients. She also epitomizes the "new" real estate agent through her use and mastery of technology. We’re proud that Susan is part of the Reinhart Team."  

Dave Lutton, President, Reinhart Realtors

With over 120 million in career real estate sales and hundreds of customer references I am qualified to be your Realtor.  As a fourth generation resident I know what the Ann Arbor area offers for residential, investment, student housing opportunities.  I have  the knowledge, experience and the drive to handle every aspect of your sale and search from evaluation to closing.

Get a positive, helpful partner for buying or selling a home: 

Throughout her 18 year real estate career, she has been recognized for her commitment to her clients with numerous awards. As Reinhart Rookie of the Year, she achieved the highest sales numbers ever recorded by a new agent.  She has been recognized for consistent production as a member of The Reinhart Presidents Club and for highest production in the Company, receiving the Charles Reinhart Award throughout her career. 

Prior to her real estate career Susan was a Director, Manager and Sr. Sales Representative in the technology services and software industry. She understands how and when to use technology to give her clients the advantage they deserve.


Local Experience

As a Realtor Susan is an expert in this local area. She brings a wealth of knowledge and expertise about buying and selling real estate here. It's not the same everywhere, so you need someone you can trust for up-to-date information. Susan is eager to serve you. Here are some of the things she can do for you:


Sell a Home
When it's time to move, you need someone who will market your home, show to prospective buyers, negotiate the purchase contract, arrange financing, oversee the inspections, handle all necessary paperwork, and supervise the closing. Susan will take care of everything you need, from start to close.


Find Your Next Home
You need someone who knows the intricate details of all of our neighborhoods.  Susan will work with you to find the right home at the right price for you, including all the neighborhood amenities that matter - not to mention the essential criteria you have for your ideal home


Professional Realtor and Trusted Friend
My #1 Goal is your #1 Goal. Susan will use your time efficiently; provide important decision making information accurately and immediately as the market changes. She will represent ONLY the full asking price to buyers and peer group and keep your confidential information confidential. When our business is complete you will consider her your go to person for ALL of your real estate needs!

My Office

Ann Arbor - East
2452 East Stadium
Ann Arbor, MI 48104


“We really appreciated all the hard work and determination Susan brought to the task of helping us purchase a home. We are so grateful for the personal attention, dedication, and especially the honesty that she brings to the profession that we are happy to recommend her to others in the community. We want to publicly honor her commitment to protecting the interests and meeting the individual needs of her clients-- even when these might be complicated. We recommend her without qualification. “

Dr's Marvin and Pam Notvetsky

"Working with Susan was a tremendous pleasure.  Her professionalism and dedication made the selling process an easy task.  We have worked with many realtors in the past, but her attention to detail and follow through truly separates her from others.  We would highly recommend her to anyone looking for an excellent agent to get the job done!“

Colleen and Chuck Braham, William Charles Custom Home Builders

“Susan N. has enjoyed tremendous success in her real estate practice for many reasons, starting with hard work and persistence.  She is high energy, a relentless negotiator, and a creative problem solver for her clients.  She also epitomizes the “new” real estate agent through her use and mastery of technology.  We’re proud that Susan is part of the Reinhart Team” Dave Lutton President of The Charles Reinhsrt Company

Dave Lutton

As first-time home buyers moving from California with a new baby, we were a bit intimidated by the prospect of finding a new home. Susan successfully led us through each stage of the process with great ease, skill and professionalism. We would highly recommend her to anyone looking for an excellent agent to get the job done!“

Leo and Shani Gonzalas

"We have worked with many agents over the years but never someone with more energy, responsibility, and hard work. Susan really goes the extra mile in all aspects of the relationship"  

Barb Brush and Bea Sweadlow

“Susan was fantastic to work with…. she not only negotiated a significant price reduction on our new home purchase but she sold our home for over asking price. We couldn’t be happier!”

Patricia Little and Ray Barbahain

“Working with Susan to market and sell our Ann Arbor home has been a real pleasure for us. Our move was a corporate relocation with a very tight timeline, requiring a very quick sale. As promised during our initial meeting with her, Susan were able to quickly put together a highly professional package to market our home that included the listing, professional photos, a virtual tour, fliers, and personal contact with other realtors and several potential buyers. She was exceptional in her ability to get our paperwork organized and put our house on the market in a very short time. Most importantly, she found three potential buyers for us on the very first day our home was listed. Once a contract was secured, Susan kept in touch via phone and email to keep us informed of the status of inspections, paperwork and questions from the buyer. The sale of our home was very easy from our perspective because she handled everything. Once the closing date was settled on, Susan continued to be available whenever we needed her; her commitment to service did not stop once the deal was sealed. In short, Susan ’s performance has been extraordinary; we would not hesitate to recommend them to our friends, neighbors, and coworkers.”

Corporate relocation

“With Susan's help we found the right house for the right price!  Susan's enthusiastic  approach toward finding us a property in Ann Arbor was well balanced….her patience and an obvious desired to see us find the right home ensured that we did not settle or compromise in any way.  On numerous occasions Susan demonstrated her commitment to act in our best interest where others had not.  She supported our decisions and offered sound advice throughout the entire process. We are so thankful to Susan for everything, we have had a great summer in Ann Arbor and we are over the moon about the house!

The Partington Family

As sellers, I needed a realtor that could not only educate us on the process, but also provide us with knowledge of intricacies of the local market. I found both in Susan. And she sold our house of over asking price.

Brad Smith and Susan Kleindshimt

My Listings
My Recent Sales